Get my offer

How much is my totaled car worth?

By the Mr. Car Cash buying deskPublished 4 min read

Straight answer

A totaled car is worth its pre-accident cash value to your insurer and a fraction of that to anyone buying it damaged. With us, a salvage title cuts an offer by roughly 40%, and a car that no longer starts is worth well under half of the same car running.

What totaled means for the value

An insurer calls a car a total loss when fixing it costs close to, or more than, what the car was worth before the damage. It is a math decision, not a verdict on the car. A ten-year-old sedan can be totaled by a crumpled fender and a popped airbag, and still start and drive.

That gives a totaled car two different values. The first is the actual cash value: what the car was worth just before the loss. That is the basis for an insurance settlement. The second is the salvage value: what the damaged car is worth as it sits today. The threshold and the figures are your insurer's to explain, so ask your adjuster how each one was worked out.

What changes the offer on a totaled car
FactorEffect on our offer
Salvage or rebuilt titleAbout 40% lower
Does not startWell under half of running value
Starts but will not driveBetween running and non-starting value
Deployed airbagsLarge extra deduction
Each damaged body panelModest deduction, capped
Flood or fire damagePriced at our minimum floor
No title in handAbout half

What the insurer pays versus what the wreck is worth

If your policy covers the damage and you let the insurer keep the car, you receive the settlement and you are done. The wreck is their problem.

If you want to keep the car, insurers commonly subtract the salvage value from your payment. The title may then carry a salvage brand. Ask your insurer for both numbers in writing, and check with the Arizona MVD on how the title will be recorded before you agree.

If you carried liability only, or the claim was denied, there is no settlement for the car. The salvage value is all there is. That is the situation where people call us: a wrecked car in the driveway, no check coming, and a registration that still costs money.

How a buyer prices a totaled car

We start from the current wholesale value of the same car undamaged, then subtract in the open:

At the time of writing, our engine prices a 2016 Toyota Camry with 90,000 miles at about $4,600. With a salvage title, the same car comes in at about $2,750. Collision damage and airbags would come off after that.

What makes one wreck worth more than another

Two totaled cars with the same damage can be far apart in price. The differences we see most:

Even at the bottom, every complete vehicle with a title has a floor with us: about $325 to $350 for cars, $450 for SUVs and vans, and $500 for pickups, at the time of writing.

See what yours is worth.

Type or say your car and watch the offer compute. Free pickup anywhere in the Valley.

Related questions

Can I sell a totaled car without fixing it?

Yes. You can sell it exactly as it sits. We buy wrecked and non-running cars across the Phoenix metro, pickup is free whether it runs or not, and you are paid before the car leaves. Repairing a total loss first rarely returns what the repair costs.

Can I keep my totaled car and still get an insurance payout?

Often, yes, if your insurer allows it. They commonly subtract the car's salvage value from your settlement, and the title may be branded salvage. Ask your adjuster for both figures in writing, and check with the Arizona MVD about the title before you decide.

Is a totaled car the same as a salvage title car?

Not exactly. Totaled is an insurance decision about one claim. Salvage is a brand on the title that follows the car afterward. A total loss often leads to a salvage title, but check with your insurer and the Arizona MVD on how yours is recorded.

What is a totaled car worth if I only had liability coverage?

Whatever a buyer will pay for it as it sits, because your own policy will not pay for the car. That is a damaged-vehicle price, not a book value. With us, a complete car with a title has a floor of about $325 to $350 at the time of writing.

Does a totaled car that still drives sell for more?

Yes. A car that does not start is worth well under half of the same car running, and one that starts but will not drive sits in between. If yours still starts and moves under its own power, say so. It makes a real difference to the offer.