My mechanic says my car is not worth fixing. Now what?
Straight answer
When a mechanic says your car is not worth fixing, it means the repair costs more than the car will be worth afterward. Get the diagnosis and quote in writing, find out what the car is worth as it sits, then choose: repair anyway, sell it, or donate it.
What the mechanic is really telling you
A good mechanic says this when the math has turned against the car. The repair quote is more than the car would sell for once fixed, or close enough that the next problem tips it over. It is an opinion about money, not a ruling that the car is worthless.
It is also not always the last word. Shops price repairs, not vehicles. Some decline big jobs on old cars because they do not want to warranty the work. Ask three things before you leave:
- What exactly failed, and how was it confirmed.
- What the full quote is, in writing.
- Whether the car is safe to drive home or should be towed.
Those answers are worth having whatever you decide next.
Check the math yourself
You need two numbers the shop did not give you: what the car is worth fixed, and what it is worth today. The gap between them is all the repair can buy.
At the time of writing, our engine prices a 2011 Chevrolet Malibu with 170,000 miles at about $735. With engine trouble, about $515. When the gap is that size and the quote runs into the thousands, your mechanic is right.
The answer changes with the vehicle. In our analysis of published trade-in values, a 2012 Toyota Tacoma at 170,000 miles kept 44% of the value of a 2020 at 82,000 miles. A Chevrolet Malibu kept 16%. The same repair can be sensible on one and hopeless on the other.
Your options when the repair does not add up
You have more choices than fix it or scrap it.
- Fix it anyway. Reasonable if you know the car's history, the rest is solid, and the repair buys a few more years without a car payment.
- Get a second opinion. Worth it on any quote in the thousands, especially if the first shop did not explain the diagnosis.
- Sell it as it sits. A buyer who takes cars with problems prices the fault in and hauls it away.
- Sell it privately. Possible, but buyers for broken cars are few and they bargain hard.
- Donate it. Ask a tax professional what you can actually deduct.
What does not work is parking it to decide later. A car sitting through a Phoenix summer loses its battery, its tires and its paint while you think.
What to do before the car leaves the shop
Shops are not parking lots. Many charge a daily storage fee once a repair has been declined, so ask about that today.
- Pay the diagnostic fee and get the findings in writing. A buyer may ask what is wrong.
- If the engine is apart, ask whether it will be put back together. A car in pieces is harder to sell.
- Take out your belongings, the garage remote and any toll transponder.
- Find the title and the keys. A missing title or missing keys both lower an offer.
- Ask whether the shop will release the car to a tow truck from its lot.
If the car is not safe to drive, do not drive it home to save a tow. Our pickup is free anywhere in the Phoenix metro, running or not, and that includes a shop's lot.
See what yours is worth.
Type or say your car and watch the offer compute. Free pickup anywhere in the Valley.
Related questions
How do I know if my mechanic is being honest?
Ask for the diagnosis in writing and ask to see the failed part or the evidence. An honest shop will explain what failed and how they confirmed it. For any quote in the thousands, a second opinion from another shop is cheap insurance.
Is a car that is not worth fixing a total loss?
Not in the insurance sense. Total loss is a term insurers use after a covered accident or event, when the repair cost approaches the car's value. A worn-out engine is a mechanical failure, which standard policies generally do not cover. Confirm with your insurer.
How much can I get for a car that is not worth fixing?
It depends on the vehicle and what is wrong. As a guide, engine trouble removes roughly a third of the value, and a car that does not start is worth well under half of a running one. Our minimum for a complete car with a title is about $325 to $350.
Should I tell a buyer what the mechanic found?
Yes, tell the buyer everything the shop found. With us, described problems are priced in up front and the offer is held for 7 days. Problems that were not described are one of only three things that can change the offer at pickup.
Can I sell a car that is still at the repair shop?
You can, as long as you own it and the shop will release it. A shop may be able to hold a car until authorized work is paid for, so settle the bill first. Have your title and ID ready, and ask about storage fees.
Keep reading
- Should I repair or sell my car?Should I repair or sell my car? Compare the repair quote, the car's value fixed and its value as it sits. A Phoenix car buyer walks through the math.
- Is it worth replacing the engine in an old car?How much does it cost to replace an engine, and is it worth it on an old car? A Phoenix car buyer explains the ranges and the repair or sell math.
- Who buys non-running cars?Who buys non running cars near me? The buyers who take a car that will not start, what a dead engine does to the price, and how free pickup works.
- How do you get rid of an old car that doesn't run?How to get rid of an old car that doesn't run in Phoenix: your five options, what the car is still worth, and the Arizona paperwork to finish the job.