Get my offer

Should I part out my car or sell it whole?

By the Mr. Car Cash buying deskPublished 4 min read

Straight answer

Sell it whole unless you have tools, storage space, several free months, and a model whose parts are in real demand. Parting out can bring more total money, but the last parts sell slowly and you still have to dispose of the shell. For most owners, one sale is the better trade.

When parting out makes sense

Parting out works for a narrow kind of car and a narrow kind of owner. All four of these have to be true.

If one of those is missing, the math stops working. Phoenix adds its own cost: pulling a transmission on a driveway in August is a job most people only start once.

Parting out a car vs. selling it whole
FactorPart it outSell it whole
Total moneyCan be higher, if everything sellsOne known price
TimeMonthsOne pickup
Tools and spaceRequiredNone
Shell disposalYour jobLeaves with the car
Main riskUnsold parts and returnsPrice changes only if the car was not as described
Best forEnthusiast models and skilled ownersOrdinary cars and busy owners

What parting out really costs

On paper, the sum of the parts is always bigger than the whole car. That number assumes every part sells, at asking price, to a buyer who shows up. In practice the engine, transmission, converter and wheels go first. Trim, glass, seats and wiring can sit for a very long time.

Then there are the costs nobody lists:

Once major parts are off, the car is no longer complete. Our minimum floor applies to complete vehicles with a title, so a half-stripped car prices as leftovers.

What selling it whole gets you

One price, one pickup, one payment. We start from current wholesale and trade-in values for the exact year, make and model, then adjust in the open. A car that does not start is worth well under half of the same car running. Engine trouble costs roughly a third, transmission trouble roughly a quarter.

To put a number on it: at the time of writing, our engine prices a 2012 Toyota Camry with 170,000 miles and engine trouble at about $1,350.

That is the figure a part-out has to beat after your costs and your hours. The floor for a complete car with a title is about $325 to $350, $450 for SUVs and vans, and $500 for pickups. The offer is held for 7 days, so you have time to price the parts before deciding.

A simple way to decide

Do the comparison on paper before you touch a wrench.

  1. Get a whole-car offer. That is your baseline.
  2. Look up what the five most valuable parts on your car actually sell for used, not what people ask.
  3. Subtract shipping, fees, and the cost of getting rid of the shell.
  4. Divide what is left by the hours you expect to spend, then double the hours.

If the part-out still wins by a wide margin, and you would enjoy the work, go ahead. If the margin is thin, take the single sale.

One exception: if the car is a classic from 1995 or older, an exotic or something rare, neither route may be right. We do not price those by formula. They go to a buyer for a personal appraisal.

See what yours is worth.

Type or say your car and watch the offer compute. Free pickup anywhere in the Valley.

Related questions

How much more money do you make parting out a car?

There is no reliable figure, and anyone quoting one is guessing. It depends on the model, the condition of the major parts and how many actually sell. Compare a whole-car offer with real sold prices for your top five parts.

What parts should I sell before junking a car?

None, if you want a whole-car price. Removing the converter, wheels or battery makes the car incomplete and lowers the offer. Aftermarket extras you added, like a stereo or a roof rack, are the exception if you can refit the originals.

How long does it take to part out a car?

Longer than most people plan for. The valuable parts can sell quickly, but the slow ones may sit for months, and the shell stays until the end. Plan on the car occupying your space for a long while.

Is it worth parting out a car with a blown engine?

Sometimes, if the rest of the car is clean and the model is popular. But the engine is usually the most valuable part, and yours is gone. In our pricing engine trouble costs roughly a third of the value, not all of it.

Can I sell a car after I have removed some parts?

Yes, but tell the buyer exactly what is missing. Our floor applies to complete vehicles with a title, so a partly stripped car is priced lower. An undisclosed missing part is one of the few things that changes an offer at pickup.