Get my offer

What do you do if your catalytic converter is stolen in Phoenix?

By the Mr. Car Cash buying deskPublished 4 min read

Straight answer

If your catalytic converter is stolen in Phoenix, file a police report, call your insurer, and do not drive the car far in that condition. Then get a repair estimate and compare it with the car's value. On an older car, replacing it can cost more than selling as is.

How to tell your catalytic converter is gone

You will know the moment you start the car. The converter sits in the exhaust pipe between the engine and the muffler, so with it cut out the engine exhausts straight under the floor. The car roars like it has no muffler, and it gets louder when you press the gas.

Other signs follow quickly:

Thieves work fast with a battery saw, and they do not care what else they cut. Check for damaged wiring, oxygen sensors and heat shields while you are down there, because those add to the repair.

Stolen catalytic converter: repair or sell as is
Your situationWhat usually makes sense
Newer car, comprehensive coverage, healthy otherwiseFile the claim and repair it
Newer car, no coverage for theftGet a written estimate, then repair if the car is worth keeping
Older car with other problemsCompare the estimate with an as-is cash offer
Car that was already near the endSell as is, with the converter marked missing

What to do first

Handle it in this order, the same day if you can.

  1. File a police report. Your insurer will likely ask for the report number.
  2. Photograph the damage. Get the cut pipes and anything else that was hit.
  3. Call your insurer. Theft of a part is typically handled under comprehensive coverage, if you carry it. Confirm what your policy pays and what your deductible is.
  4. Limit driving. The car will usually run, but it is loud and the exhaust is venting under the cabin. It is not a condition to drive in every day.
  5. Get a written estimate. Ask the shop to price the converter, the pipe work and any sensors separately.

Do not order the cheapest converter you can find online before a shop looks at the car. The wrong part can leave you with a check engine light and a failed emissions test.

Repair it or sell the car as it sits

The repair cost varies widely by vehicle and shop. On some trucks, SUVs and hybrids it is a large bill. And in metro Phoenix the car generally has to pass an emissions test to renew registration, which it will not do without a converter.

Here is the other side of the math. In our pricing, a missing catalytic converter is a flat deduction of about $250 at the time of writing. An aftermarket one is about $100. At the time of writing, our engine prices a 2010 Toyota Prius with 160,000 miles at about $1,550, and the same car with the converter missing at about $1,300.

So compare two numbers: your repair cost after the deductible, and the gap between those offers. If the car is newer and otherwise healthy, repair it. If it is old and this was the last straw, selling it as is often costs you less.

How to make your car a harder target

Nothing makes a car theft-proof. The goal is to make yours slower and louder to work on than the one parked next to it.

Trucks, SUVs and hybrids are common targets. Tall vehicles are easy to slide under, and some converters carry more precious metal than others.

See what yours is worth.

Type or say your car and watch the offer compute. Free pickup anywhere in the Valley.

Related questions

Can you drive a car without a catalytic converter?

The car will usually run, but you should not keep driving it that way. It is very loud, exhaust vents under the cabin, the check engine light stays on, and it will not pass an emissions test. Drive it only as far as you need to get it repaired or sold.

Does insurance cover a stolen catalytic converter?

Typically yes, under comprehensive coverage, if you carry it. Liability-only policies generally do not cover theft of parts from your own car. Your deductible applies, so on an older vehicle the payout may be small. Confirm the details with your insurer.

Why do thieves steal catalytic converters?

They steal them for the precious metals inside, which scrap buyers pay for. A converter can be cut off with a battery saw in a couple of minutes, it has no serial number tied to the car unless you add one, and it is easy to carry away.

Is an aftermarket catalytic converter worth less than the original?

Yes. Aftermarket converters generally contain less precious metal than factory ones, so they are worth less as a part. In our pricing an aftermarket converter is a flat deduction of about $100 at the time of writing, compared with about $250 for a missing one.

Which vehicles are targeted most for catalytic converter theft?

Trucks, SUVs and hybrids are common targets. Trucks and SUVs sit high, so a thief can slide under without a jack. Hybrid converters tend to stay cleaner and are valued for that. Any vehicle parked outside in a dark, quiet spot is easier to hit.