Get my offer

What is the most common reason for a check engine light?

By the Mr. Car Cash buying deskPublished 4 min read

Straight answer

The most common reasons for a check engine light are a loose or worn gas cap and a failing oxygen sensor. Worn spark plugs, bad ignition coils and a failing catalytic converter follow close behind. A steady light means get it checked soon. A flashing light means stop driving.

The usual causes, from cheap to expensive

The light means the car's computer saw a reading outside its normal range and stored a code. The usual triggers:

The first few are commonly minor repairs. A catalytic converter often costs well into four figures. The code tells a shop where to start looking, not which part to buy.

Common check engine light causes
CauseTypical repair sizeHow urgent
Loose or worn gas capMinorLow: tighten or replace, then recheck
Oxygen sensorMinor to moderateFix soon; fuel economy suffers
Spark plugs or ignition coilsMinor to moderateHigh if the light flashes
Mass airflow sensorMinor to moderateFix soon; can cause stalling
Vapor system leakMinor to moderateLow, but the light stays on
Catalytic converterMajorDiagnose the cause before replacing

Steady light or flashing light

This is the part that matters for safety.

A steady light means a fault was stored but the car is not in immediate danger. If it drives normally, you can usually finish your trip. Tighten the gas cap until it clicks, then get the code read within a few days. After a gas cap fix, the light can take several drives to go out.

A flashing light means an active misfire. Unburned fuel is going into the exhaust, where it can overheat and destroy the catalytic converter. Ease off, pull over when it is safe and shut the engine off. Have the car towed.

Also stop if the light comes with a red oil pressure or temperature warning, heavy shaking, a loss of power or a fuel smell. Those are not wait-and-see symptoms.

How to find out what the code is

Cars and light trucks sold in the United States since 1996 have a diagnostic port, usually under the dash near the steering column. A basic code reader plugs in and shows a code such as P0420 or P0300. Many parts stores will read codes at no charge.

Reading a code is safe to do yourself. Diagnosing it is different. A single code for a lean fuel mixture can come from a vacuum leak, a dirty sensor, a weak fuel pump or an exhaust leak. Replacing parts by guesswork gets expensive quickly.

Do not clear the code just to make the light go away. The fault is still there, and the car's self-tests start over, which can cause trouble at an emissions test. If the cause is not obvious, pay a shop for a proper diagnosis.

What a check engine light does to the car's value

Less than most sellers fear. In our pricing, warning lights are a small deduction. Engine trouble is the big one, at roughly a third of the car's value. So what matters is what is behind the light.

A light caused by a gas cap or a sensor barely moves the number. A light caused by a failing engine is priced as engine trouble. A missing catalytic converter is a flat deduction of about $250 at the time of writing, and an aftermarket one about $100.

In the Phoenix area there is one more cost. Vehicles registered here generally must pass an emissions test to renew registration, and a failed test stops the renewal. It does not stop a sale to a buyer like us. If the repair quote is larger than the difference it makes to the car's value, selling it as it sits is a fair option.

See what yours is worth.

Type or say your car and watch the offer compute. Free pickup anywhere in the Valley.

Related questions

Can I drive with the check engine light on?

You can usually drive for a short while with a steady light if the car runs normally. Get the code read within a few days. If the light is flashing, or the car shakes, loses power or overheats, pull over safely and have it towed.

Will the check engine light reset itself?

Sometimes. If the cause was temporary, such as a loose gas cap, the light commonly goes out after several drives once the system retests and passes. If it stays on for more than a few days, the fault is still present and the code needs to be read.

How much does it cost to diagnose a check engine light?

Reading the code is often free at parts stores. A real diagnosis at a shop is commonly billed as about an hour of labor, which varies by shop. Ask the price before you authorize it, and ask whether it is credited toward the repair.

Will a car pass emissions with the check engine light on?

It often will not. A lit check engine light commonly leads to a failed test, though the details depend on the vehicle, so confirm with the testing program. In the Phoenix area a failed test stops a registration renewal. It does not stop a sale.

Can I sell a car with the check engine light on?

You can sell a car with the check engine light on. Tell the buyer the light is on and how the car runs. In our pricing a warning light alone is a small deduction, and we do not require an emissions test before buying.