How much should I sell my car for?
Straight answer
Ask slightly above the middle of the published private party range, and expect a dealer or cash buyer to pay closer to trade-in value. Adjust about half a percent for every 1,000 miles above or below typical. Excellent condition adds about 7% over good, and fair takes off about 9.5%.
Start with the right kind of price
Most pricing mistakes come from starting with the wrong number. Published pricing guides give at least three for the same car:
- Retail: what a dealer asks on the lot, after cleaning, repairs and overhead.
- Private party: what one owner might get from another.
- Trade-in: what a dealer may credit you, close to wholesale.
If you are selling it yourself, private party is your number. Do not price off dealer listings. A dealer's asking price includes work and risk you are not offering. If you are selling to a dealer or a cash buyer like us, trade-in is the honest comparison. We start from current wholesale and trade-in values for the exact year, make and model, then adjust in the open.
| Your car compared with typical | Approximate adjustment |
|---|---|
| 10,000 miles under typical for its age | About 5% higher |
| 10,000 miles over typical for its age | About 5% lower |
| Excellent instead of good condition | About 7% higher |
| Fair instead of good condition | About 9.5% lower |
| Transmission trouble | About a quarter lower |
| Engine trouble | About a third lower |
| Salvage or rebuilt title | About 40% lower |
Adjust for your mileage and condition
Typical use is about 12,000 miles a year. Multiply by your car's age and compare. In our analysis of 121 published trade-in values, value moved about 0.55% for every 1,000 miles, up or down. So a car 20,000 miles under typical deserves around 10% more, and one 20,000 over deserves around 10% less.
Then grade the condition without flattering yourself. Most cars that owners call excellent are good. In the values we compared, excellent was worth about 7% more than good, and fair was about 9.5% less.
Phoenix adds its own wear. Faded clear coat, a cracked dash and a tired A/C are common here and buyers expect to see them on older cars. They still move a car from good toward fair. Price for the car you have.
Leave room, but not much
Published values are ranges, not prices. In our analysis the range for a single car was usually about $1,650 wide. That tells you how much honest disagreement there is about any one car.
For a private sale, ask a little above the figure you would accept. Buyers expect to negotiate and feel better when they win something. Do not pad it heavily. An overpriced car sits, the listing goes stale, and the buyers who do call assume something is wrong with it.
Decide your floor before the first message arrives, and write it down. It is much easier to turn down a low offer in a parking lot when you already know your number. If two weeks pass with no serious interest, the market has answered. Lower the price.
When the right price is a cash offer
A clean, late-model car with a clear title will often bring more in a private sale than from us. If you have the patience for calls and test drives, sell it that way.
The further a car is from clean, the worse private selling works. Private buyers do not subtract the repair cost. They subtract the repair cost, the risk and the inconvenience, or they simply leave. In our pricing, engine trouble costs roughly a third of the value, transmission trouble roughly a quarter, and a salvage or rebuilt title roughly 40%. A car that does not start is worth well under half of the same car running.
For those cars, the realistic selling price is what a buyer who handles them every day will pay, with free pickup and payment before the car leaves.
See what yours is worth.
Type or say your car and watch the offer compute. Free pickup anywhere in the Valley.
Related questions
Should I price my car higher to leave room to negotiate?
A little, yes. Ask slightly above the lowest figure you would accept so there is room to give. Heavy padding backfires. An overpriced car sits unsold, and buyers who see an old listing assume there is a problem with the car.
How much less will a dealer pay than a private buyer?
It varies by car, and we will not put a made-up percentage on it. A dealer or cash buyer pays near wholesale because they must recondition, title and resell the car. The gap is widest on clean late-model cars and narrowest on rough or broken ones.
How do I price a car that needs repairs?
Start from the value of the same car in running order, then take off more than the repair bill, because buyers also price the risk. In our pricing, engine trouble removes roughly a third of the value and transmission trouble roughly a quarter.
What paperwork do I need once I agree on a price in Arizona?
You need the title. Arizona titles include a space for a notary or MVD agent to witness the seller's signature, and requirements can differ when the buyer is a licensed dealer, so do not sign in advance. Keep your plate and file a sold notice within 10 days.
Should I fix small things before selling my car?
Cheap, visible things, yes: a wash, a cleared-out interior, a dead bulb. Expensive repairs rarely return what they cost. In our pricing, warning lights and a dead A/C are small deductions next to an engine or transmission problem, so spend carefully.
Keep reading
- How much is my car worth?How much is my car worth? A Phoenix cash buyer shows what sets the number: wholesale value, mileage, condition and title, with our own data.
- Trade-in value vs. a cash offer: what is the difference?Trade in value and a cash offer both sit near wholesale, but they work differently. A Phoenix buyer explains each one and how to compare them fairly.
- How do you sell a car?How to sell a car in seven steps: find its value, gather the title, pick a buyer, get paid safely, then file the paperwork. Includes Arizona rules.
- How do you sell a car in Arizona?How to sell a car in Arizona: get the title ready, pick a buyer, sign at the right moment, keep your plate and file a sold notice within 10 days.