How much is my car worth?
Straight answer
Your car is worth what a buyer will pay today for that exact year, make, model, mileage and condition, not a single book number. In our analysis, the published trade-in range for one car was usually about $1,650 wide. Mileage, whether it runs, and title status move the figure most.
What actually sets the number
Three things set the number: what the same car brings at wholesale right now, how yours differs from a typical one, and who is buying. A dealer taking a trade, a private buyer and a cash buyer like us all pay different amounts for the same car.
We start from current wholesale and trade-in values for the exact year, make and model. Then we adjust in the open for mileage, whether it runs, body damage, mechanical trouble, title status and keys. At the time of writing, our engine prices a 2015 Honda Accord with 120,000 miles at about $3,325.
What you paid, what you still owe and what you spent on tires last year do not set the number. The market does.
| Factor | Approximate effect on value |
|---|---|
| Mileage above or below 12,000 a year | About 0.5% per 1,000 miles |
| Excellent instead of good condition | About 7% more |
| Fair instead of good condition | About 9.5% less |
| Does not start | Well under half of running value |
| Engine trouble | About a third less |
| Transmission trouble | About a quarter less |
| Salvage or rebuilt title | About 40% less |
| No title in hand | About half |
How much mileage changes the value
Mileage is judged against about 12,000 miles a year. A ten-year-old car is expected to show around 120,000. Above that, value comes off. Below it, value goes on.
In November 2026 we compared 121 published trade-in values for popular models. Value moved about 0.55% for every 1,000 miles, in both directions. Our own pricing uses roughly half a percent per 1,000 miles.
So 20,000 extra miles costs around 10% of the car's value. That stings on a three-year-old pickup. On a 2009 sedan it is a small number, because 10% of not much is not much. Owners of older cars worry about the odometer more than they need to. On an old car, whether it starts matters far more than the mileage.
How condition and title change the value
Condition grades matter less than people expect. In the published values we compared, excellent condition was worth about 7% more than good, and fair was about 9.5% less. Real problems are what move the price:
- Does not start: worth well under half of the same car running.
- Engine trouble: roughly a third of the value gone.
- Transmission trouble: roughly a quarter.
- Salvage or rebuilt title: about 40% off.
- No title in hand: about half off.
Warning lights and a dead A/C are small by comparison, even in a Phoenix summer. Each damaged body panel takes a modest bite, with a cap. Deployed airbags are a large extra deduction. A loan does not lower the offer at all. It only changes the paperwork.
Why three sources give you three numbers
Published pricing guides show a range, not a price. In our analysis the range for a single car was usually about $1,650 wide. On a late-model truck that is noise. On a cheap older car it can be most of the value, which makes the guide close to useless at the low end.
The guides also stop short of the bottom. Published trade-in values rarely went below about $600, however rough the car. Real junk cars sell for less than that every day, so a guide can overstate what a non-runner will bring.
Then there is the type of number. Retail is what a dealer asks. Private party is what a patient seller might get. Trade-in and cash offers sit below both, because the buyer still has to recondition, title and resell the car.
When a cash offer is not your best number
If your car is late-model, clean and running well, a private sale will often bring more than any cash buyer, us included. You pay for it in time: photos, messages, test drives with strangers and a trip to handle the title. If you have the patience, that is a fair trade.
A cash offer makes more sense the further the car is from perfect. Private buyers walk away from a blown engine, a salvage title or a car that will not start. Those are the cars we price every day. Every complete vehicle with a title also has a minimum floor with us: about $325 to $350 for cars, $450 for SUVs and vans, and $500 for pickups, at the time of writing.
See what yours is worth.
Type or say your car and watch the offer compute. Free pickup anywhere in the Valley.
Related questions
How do I find out what my car is worth for free?
Type the year, make, model and mileage, or paste the VIN, on www.mrcarcash.com. You answer a few questions about condition, title and keys, then sign up to unlock the offer and the line-by-line math. It costs nothing, and the offer holds for 7 days.
Is trade-in value the same as what my car is worth?
No. Trade-in value is what a dealer may credit you toward another car, and it sits below private party and retail prices. It is a fair guide to a wholesale number, but published ranges are wide: usually about $1,650 for a single car in our analysis.
Does owing money on my car lower its value?
No. A loan does not change what the car is worth or what we offer. It changes the paperwork, because the lender must release its lien before ownership can transfer. If you owe more than the offer, you would need to settle the difference with your lender.
What is my car worth if it does not run?
A car that does not start is worth well under half of the same car running. One that starts but will not drive sits in between. Every complete vehicle with a title still has a floor with us, about $325 to $350 for cars at the time of writing.
Do new tires or recent repairs raise my car's value?
Rarely by what they cost. Buyers price the year, make, model, mileage and condition, and a car is expected to have working tires and brakes. Recent work can help a private sale move faster. It seldom changes a wholesale or cash offer by much.
Keep reading
- How much is my car worth by VIN?How much is my car worth by VIN? What the 17 characters tell a Phoenix buyer, what they leave out, and how mileage and condition finish the price.
- How much should I sell my car for?How much should I sell my car for? A Phoenix buyer explains which price to start from, how to adjust for miles and condition, and when to take cash.
- Trade-in value vs. a cash offer: what is the difference?Trade in value and a cash offer both sit near wholesale, but they work differently. A Phoenix buyer explains each one and how to compare them fairly.
- How many miles is too many for a used car?How many miles is too many for a used car? A Phoenix buyer explains the 12,000 miles a year rule and why the model matters more than the odometer.