Get my offer

What are the signs it is time to sell your car?

By the Mr. Car Cash buying deskPublished 4 min read

Straight answer

It is time to sell your car when a year of repair bills approaches its value, or when you no longer trust it. Other signs: a failing engine or transmission, repeated breakdowns, a big service coming due, and a car that no longer fits your life.

The money signs

Cars rarely die all at once. They get expensive first. These are the signs we would act on:

One of these is a nudge. Two together is a decision.

Sell it or keep it: a quick read
What you are seeingWhat it usually means
Wear items only: brakes, tires, batteryKeep it and fix it
A year of repair bills near the car's valueTime to sell
Engine or transmission quote on an older carRun the numbers before repairing
Repeated breakdowns or overheatingSell while it still runs
Clean, late-model car with a small problemFix it; consider a private sale

The reliability signs

Money is only half of it. A car you cannot trust costs you in other ways.

In Phoenix a breakdown is more than an inconvenience. A stalled car on the shoulder of the 101 in July is a safety problem for you and anyone riding with you. If you would not send a family member across the Valley in it, that tells you something.

Why timing changes the price

The biggest drop in a car's value is not age. It is the day the car stops starting. A car that does not start is worth well under half of the same car running. One that starts but will not drive sits in between.

At the time of writing, our engine prices a 2012 Honda Odyssey with 170,000 miles at about $1,125 running, and about $455 if it does not start.

So the expensive mistake is driving a failing car until it quits. Selling while it still runs, with the engine or transmission trouble described honestly, usually brings much more than selling it dead.

Mileage matters less than people think. Value moves roughly half a percent for every 1,000 miles above or below typical. A few more months of normal driving costs little. A failed engine in those months costs a lot.

When to keep the car instead

Plenty of older cars are worth keeping. Hold on to yours if the repairs are ordinary wear items, the engine and transmission are healthy, and it still does what you need. A paid-off car with predictable costs is cheap transportation.

Which vehicle you own matters too. In our analysis of published trade-in values, pickups held value far better than the same brand's cars. At the same age and mileage, mainstream domestic, Korean, Nissan and German sedans were worth roughly half of a comparable Toyota or Honda. A vehicle that holds value gives you more room to repair.

And if your car is a clean, late-model vehicle, a private sale may bring more than we would pay, if you have the patience for showings and paperwork. We would sooner say so than pretend otherwise.

See what yours is worth.

Type or say your car and watch the offer compute. Free pickup anywhere in the Valley.

Related questions

At what mileage should I sell my car?

There is no single mileage. We judge miles against about 12,000 a year, and value moves roughly half a percent per 1,000 miles either way. The condition of the engine and transmission, and whether the car runs, matter far more than a round number on the odometer.

Is it better to sell a car before it breaks down?

Yes, a running car is worth much more than a dead one. A car that does not start is worth well under half of the same car running. If a major failure looks likely, selling while it still drives protects most of the value.

What time of year is best to sell a car in Phoenix?

Our offers follow current wholesale values and the car's condition, not the calendar. What does matter here is summer. Heat finishes off weak batteries, cooling systems and transmissions, so a car with a known problem is safer sold before July than after it fails.

Should I sell my car or trade it in?

It depends on the car. A dealer trade-in is convenient when you are buying there. A cash buyer makes sense when the car has problems or you are not replacing it. A clean late-model car may bring the most in a private sale, with more effort.

Do I need to fix warning lights before selling?

No, not when selling to us. Warning lights are a small deduction compared with engine or transmission trouble, and paying a shop to chase a light rarely returns the cost. Tell us which lights are on so the offer holds at pickup.