How many miles is too many for a used car?
Straight answer
No single mileage is too many, but most buyers get cautious once a car passes about 12,000 miles for every year of its age. Past 150,000 miles the model matters more than the number. In our analysis, a 2012 Toyota Tacoma at 170,000 miles kept 44% of a 2020's value.
The 12,000 miles a year rule
Buyers do not judge mileage in isolation. They judge it against age. The working figure is about 12,000 miles a year. A five-year-old car is expected to show around 60,000. A ten-year-old car, around 120,000.
A car well above that line is high-mileage for its age. A car well below it is low. Both get priced accordingly. In our analysis of 121 published trade-in values, value moved about 0.55% for every 1,000 miles, in both directions.
How the miles were put on matters too. A commuter that ran the 101 and I-10 at steady speed has had an easier life than a car with half the miles spent idling in parking lots in July. The odometer cannot tell those apart. Service records and a cold start can.
| Age of car | Typical mileage | High for its age if above |
|---|---|---|
| 3 years | 36,000 | About 36,000 |
| 5 years | 60,000 | About 60,000 |
| 8 years | 96,000 | About 96,000 |
| 10 years | 120,000 | About 120,000 |
| 12 years | 144,000 | About 144,000 |
| 15 years | 180,000 | About 180,000 |
Why the model matters more than the odometer
We compared what a 2012 model at 170,000 miles is worth against a 2020 of the same model at 82,000. The share of value kept ran from 44% down to 10%:
- Toyota Tacoma: 44%
- Toyota Corolla: 37%
- Honda Civic: 30%
- Toyota RAV4: 27%
- Honda Accord: 24%
- Ford Explorer: 17%
- Nissan Rogue: 16%
- Jeep Grand Cherokee: 10%
Same age, same miles, a spread of more than four to one. The market is telling you which cars it trusts at 170,000. At the same age and mileage, mainstream domestic, Korean, Nissan and German sedans were worth roughly half of a comparable Toyota or Honda. Older German luxury cars were worth less than economy cars with more miles.
What high mileage does to the price
The math is simple. Every 1,000 miles above typical takes off roughly half a percent of the car's value. A car 30,000 miles over the line gives up around 15%.
On a newer car that is real money. On an older one it shrinks, because the percentage applies to a small number. At the time of writing, our engine prices a 2012 Toyota Corolla with 170,000 miles at about $1,925 and a 2012 Chevrolet Malibu with the same miles at about $850.
There is also a floor. Published trade-in values rarely went below about $600, however rough the car. With us, every complete vehicle with a title has a minimum, so mileage alone never takes a car to zero.
What to check on a high-mileage car in Phoenix
Heat ages a car here faster than miles do. On anything past 120,000, look at these before the odometer:
- Cooling system: hoses, radiator, water pump, and any sign of past overheating.
- Battery and A/C: both work hard for half the year.
- Transmission: slipping, harsh shifts or burnt-smelling fluid.
- Rubber and plastic: cracked belts, door seals, dash and trim.
- Warning lights: a check engine light can also stop an emissions test and a registration renewal.
- Records: oil changes on paper beat any promise.
In our pricing, engine trouble costs roughly a third of a car's value and transmission trouble roughly a quarter. Those two decide whether a high-mileage car is a bargain or someone else's problem. The miles are only a hint.
See what yours is worth.
Type or say your car and watch the offer compute. Free pickup anywhere in the Valley.
Related questions
Is 100,000 miles a lot for a used car?
Not by itself. It is about what an eight-year-old car should show at 12,000 miles a year. On a four-year-old car it is high and the price should reflect that. On a twelve-year-old car it is low. Judge it against age and the model's reputation.
Is 200,000 miles too many for a used car?
For most models it is near the end of the useful range, so pay accordingly. Some pickups and Toyota and Honda cars still carry real value there. In our analysis, a 2012 Tacoma at 170,000 miles kept 44% of a 2020 model's value.
Is an older car with low miles better than a newer car with high miles?
Not automatically. Age wears out rubber, seals and plastics whatever the odometer says, and Phoenix heat speeds that up. A newer car with steady freeway miles and service records is often the safer buy. Low miles on a fifteen-year-old car do not make it young.
Do high miles matter less on a truck?
Mostly, yes. In our analysis pickups held value far better than the same brand's cars. A 2012 Ram 1500 at 170,000 miles kept 32% of a 2020's value and a Chevrolet Silverado 29%. The Ford F-150 was the exception at 15%.
Can I sell a car with more than 200,000 miles?
Yes. We buy high-mileage cars across the Phoenix metro, running or not, with free pickup. Mileage lowers the offer by roughly half a percent per 1,000 miles over typical, but every complete vehicle with a title has a minimum cash floor with us.
Keep reading
- How long do cars last?How long do cars last? A Phoenix car buyer on the 200,000 mile rule of thumb, what heat does to lifespan, and which models hold value longest.
- How much is my car worth?How much is my car worth? A Phoenix cash buyer shows what sets the number: wholesale value, mileage, condition and title, with our own data.
- What are the signs it is time to sell your car?When to sell your car: the money signs, the reliability signs, and why selling before it stops running matters most. From a Phoenix car buyer.
- What does Phoenix heat do to a car's value?Phoenix sun damage lowers car value less than you think. See what faded paint, a cracked dash and a dead A/C cost next to real mechanical trouble.